New York Pizzeria — authentic New York-style pizzeria serving Legacy SE Calgary and Okotoks, Alberta
Our Story

About New York Pizzeria Authentic New York-Style Pizza Calgary's Slice of New York in Legacy & Okotoks

Two Alberta locations. One mission: sharing happiness, one pizza at a time — with fresh dough made daily and 100% whole milk mozzarella.

Discover Our Journey
Original G pizza with double pepperoni and double cheese on fresh daily dough at New York Pizzeria Calgary
2020 Serving
Since

A Taste of New York

New York Pizzeria is an independently owned, family-oriented pizzeria bringing authentic New York-style pizza to Alberta. Since opening our doors in 2020, we have been dedicated to one mission: serving exceptional food with genuine hospitality. Rooted in the spirit of classic New York pizzerias, every element of the experience — from the dough to the sauce to the cheese — is crafted with authenticity and care.

Our dough is made fresh every single day, and our signature pizza sauce comes from a unique recipe that balances nostalgia with flavour innovation. Every pizza is topped with 100% whole milk mozzarella for rich, authentic flavour. Beyond pizza, our extensive menu features oven-baked pasta, chicken wings in dozens of flavours, fresh salads, calzones and desserts.

From our original Legacy location in SE Calgary to our Okotoks pizzeria, we serve our communities with a family-friendly, lively atmosphere that blends casual comfort with the buzz of a New York city pizzeria. Whether you dine in, order for pickup, or have it delivered, we aim to bring a slice of the city to the heart of Alberta — with gluten-friendly, vegetarian and dairy-free options for every guest.

"Sharing Happiness, One Pizza At A Time — that's the promise behind every fresh batch of dough, every house-made sauce, and every pizza we serve." — New York Pizzeria

Our Philosophy

Every pizza tells a story. Every bite brings a slice of New York to the heart of Alberta.

Authenticity

New York-style done right — fresh dough made daily, a house-made signature sauce, and 100% whole milk mozzarella. No shortcuts, just authentic recipes crafted with care.

Family-Friendly

We serve with genuine hospitality in a lively, family-friendly atmosphere that blends casual comfort with the energy of a true New York city pizzeria.

Community

Proudly serving Okotoks and SE Calgary's Legacy community with dine-in, takeout, delivery and catering — building connections one pizza at a time.

2020 Serving Since
2 Alberta Locations
100 + Menu Items

What Our Guests Say

Don't just take our word for it. Hear from the guests who've made New York Pizzeria their favourite spot for pizza in Calgary and Okotoks.

"The pizza is delicious — not too oily and the dough is soft. Overall the customer service is great. You can order ahead, which I would recommend. Best pizza we've ever had."

Legacy Diner, Calgary Google Review

"Excellent pizza, always hot out of the box. Crust is the perfect thickness. Outstanding customer service — they treat their patrons with respect and really care about the experience."

Okotoks Customer Google Review

"Fresh pizza, unforgettable taste, and family-friendly vibes. One bite and you'll know — Calgary's slice of New York is closer than you think!"

Happy Customer Google Review

"Amazing customer service. The pizza was also very good — best we've ever had. You can order ahead, which I would recommend for a smooth experience. Will definitely be coming back."

Repeat Customer, Legacy Google Review

Ready to Dig In?

Whether you're craving our signature Broadway pizza, saucy wings, or oven-baked pasta, we're ready to serve you at both our Alberta locations — in Legacy SE Calgary and Okotoks.

New York Pizzeria Okotoks

10 D'Arcy Ranch Dr, Unit 110
Okotoks, AB T1S 5V9

(403) 821-5678 View Location Details

New York Pizzeria Legacy, Calgary

180 Legacy Main St SE, Unit #150
Calgary, AB T2X 4R9

(403) 233-0303