Specialty Pizza

Butter Chicken Pizza

A Bold Fusion Favourite

Our Butter Chicken Pizza blends South Asian flavours with a classic Italian-style crust — creamy butter chicken sauce, tender butter chicken, chili flakes, mozzarella, red onions and green pepper.

Open Late, 7 Days
Creamy & Flavourful
Specialty Pizza
Order Now View Menu
Butter Chicken Pizza at New York Pizzeria in Calgary and Okotoks
About This Dish

About Our Butter Chicken Pizza

Butter Chicken Pizza is a standout specialty at New York Pizzeria, blending South Asian flavours with our authentic New York-style crust. We layer creamy butter chicken sauce, tender butter chicken, mozzarella, red onions and green pepper, finished with a touch of chili flakes.

It's a bold, crowd-pleasing fusion that has become a signature favourite in Calgary and Okotoks. Enjoy it for dine-in, takeout or delivery at both our Okotoks and Legacy, SE Calgary locations.

Customer Reviews

What Customers Say

Pizza Lover

Okotoks, AB

"The Butter Chicken Pizza at New York Pizzeria is incredible — fresh, hot and loaded with flavour. Easily one of the best in Okotoks!"

May 2026

SE Calgary Foodie

Legacy, Calgary

"Ordered the Butter Chicken Pizza for delivery to Legacy and it arrived hot and perfect. Authentic New York-style taste — highly recommend!"

April 2026

Local Regular

Calgary & Okotoks

"Our family’s go-to. The Butter Chicken Pizza never disappoints — generous portions and genuine hospitality every visit."

March 2026

Order Now

Ready to Try Butter Chicken Pizza?

Order online for pickup or delivery in Okotoks and Legacy, SE Calgary.

Order from Okotoks Order from Legacy (Calgary)
Visit Us

Our Locations

Two convenient locations in Okotoks and Legacy, SE Calgary

New York Pizzeria - Okotoks

10 D'Arcy Ranch Dr, Unit 110, Okotoks, AB T1S 5V9
(403) 821-5678
Sun–Thu: 11 AM–11 PM · Fri–Sat: 11 AM–1 AM
Get Directions Order Online

New York Pizzeria - Legacy

180 Legacy Main St SE, Unit #150, Calgary, AB T2X 4R9
(403) 233-0303
Sun–Thu: 11 AM–12 AM · Fri–Sat: 11 AM–2 AM
Get Directions Order Online